Caring for Illness - Statewide - Commercial Managed Care

Plan Appropriate
Treatment for URI
Appropriate
Testing for
Pharyngitis
Use of Apppropriate
Medications for People
With Asthma (Ages 5-17)
ADHD Initiation
Aetna 82 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 82 Significantly better than Statewide Average 89 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 39
BSNENY 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 77 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 97  48 Significantly better than Statewide Average
Blue Choice 89 Significantly better than Statewide Average 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  34
CDPHP 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 73 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 95  40
CIGNA 86 Significantly better than Statewide Average 79  89 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 40
Community Blue 83 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 54 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 93  36
Empire 81 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 97 Significantly better than Statewide Average 34
GHI HMO Select 84  77  94  32
HIP 85  75 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 92 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 23 Significantly worse than Statewide Average
Health Net 86 Significantly better than Statewide Average 83 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  32
Independent Health 84  74 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 99 Significantly better than Statewide Average 32
MDNY 80 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  46
MVP 85  75 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 95  42 Significantly better than Statewide Average
Oxford 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 85 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  40
Preferred Care 89 Significantly better than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  34
UnitedHealthCare of New York 85  82 Significantly better than Statewide Average 97  41
Univera HealthCare 85  63 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 95  39
Upstate HMO 85  77  93  --
Statewide Average 85 80 95 36
National Average 83 73 * 33
Significantly better than Statewide Average Significantly better than the statewide average.
Significantly worse than Statewide Average Significantly worse than the statewide average.
-- Sample size too small to report.
* No national average available.

Note Plans without symbols are consistent with the statewide average.

National average is based on data from the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA).